Then move to the outside of the tarp and stake out the guylines of the tarp on both sides, making the tarp stand up. Andrew has stated that the HR1 started out with sloped sides, I wish it had stayed that way. The Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL is a great ultralight, non-freestanding tent. 4) There should have been two more loops midway along the lower edges of the outder doors to allow the long doors to be put under some tension. The grommet at the bottom of the tent doesn’t allow your trekking pole to really stab into the ground, which doesn’t allow the poles to stand up perfectly. i csnt find anything:(. If the same shelter were to be made today, it would definitely be lighter. If it’s not buggy, I would not take the inner tent. 5) I am probably not pitching this quite right yet, but I find the fabric to be somewhat floppy, even with everything fully staked out, poles at ~49 inches, tenstion straps pulled, guylines taut. This tent was rated one of the 12 best tents by But it shouldn’t be saggy. If you want, you can attach the inner … Before parting ways with the company, he developed a plan to overhaul this tent. My goal is to explain the strengths of weaknesses of the product and the environmental conditions that it will work well or poorly in. High Route 2 Tarp Sierra Designs. Maybe we’ll reconsider. Clip flashlight 3 CD: Because of this I was pretty nervous to see how it’d turn out, but after the first time setting up the tent, every time after that was a breeze. 4) I am finding that pulling the guylines slightly towards the center of the doors seems to improve the resistance of the tent to side pushes. 4. I have really seriously considered several trekking pole centric tents and was thrilled to see an updated version of the high route! It looks very capable of dealing with the TGO Challenge weather. Everything else — including the HR1 — is at best an evolution in existing design, offering something different and somehow better (though not necessarily across-the-board better). Set your trekking poles to 119 cm, and insert the poles, pole handle up, inside the corner of the tarp. Everything I found a few months ago when tent shopping that is lighter (that does in fact have a better ratio) is also smaller. Once I got the hang of it, I found this tent extremely easy to set up, relieving my non-freestanding-tent fears. Maybe some readers out there who have hiked the trail have some input. They maximize the usability of interior space, because perimeter space is not lost to low-angled walls. This post contains affiliate links, which helps to support content on this website. The X-mid and the HR look superficially similar – nothing more than a rotated inner to provide for larger vestibule. If it starts to rain and you’ve only set up the tent body, you would have to take it down, set up the tarp, and then set the tent body up again inside the tarp. Being out in the wilderness for over five months changed my life in the most positive ways, and I'm yearning to find ways to bring that positivity into society. Mountainsmith are very reasonably priced and use heavier fabrics but the designs are limited and so-so. Door functionality – absolutely, the moment you stake it down it becomes unusable. I think this shelter will take a step in putting Sierra Designs back on the map for long-distance hikers. Voila. Tarp only weight: 1 pound, 1 ounce If you want more room inside the fly when the inner tent pitched, you can adjust the corner connection lengths in order to “shift” the inner tent around inside, like more flush to one side. The fly is 48″ wide; the inner, 30″. I Am open to the idea of a hammock but concerned about places on the MST where there are no trees or other structures to hang a hammock. To do that I needed to keep the pole length to around 120cm and use the guy lines to provide tension. In addition to the improvement in sleeping comfort, this also solves the problem of what to do with your pack at night. While this is usually not an issue on soft ground, I can see how it could become more of an issue on sandy beach, rocks, snow and so on, at least compared to self-supporting tents. I ignored tents like those 4 months ago when I was searching for a replacement for the SD Clip 3 CD because they were no better about setting up in the rain. I was impressed this tent had two side doors and still weighs less than two pounds. The HR1 mk1 has a lot going for it. In particular, the High Route offered massive interior volume, double doors and double door awnings, #5 double zippers, durable 20d and 30d fabrics, taped seams, and line-locks and ample cordage. Designed as an incredibly versatile year-round hiking shelter, the High Route is a 31 ounce ultralight shelter that utilizes trekking poles. My old clip flashlight 3 CD still has a better space to weight ratio than any double wall tent I can find 15 years later. Fast and free shipping free returns cash on … If you decide to support another brand besides Sierra Designs, MLD would be a good choice.) Did your feet have good clearance from the outer? I find 1ft vestibules of fairly limited utility and prefer to place the inner almost flush with one of the doors, with just enough room for shoes, with most gear going in on the other side. It is fussy down there with three straps each going their own way. Could you give your thoughts on the functionality of the HR 1 versus the Tensegrity Elite. While it features excellent ventilation and a side vestibule, one of the stand-out features of this tent are its tent poles, which collapse down to 12.5″, making them extra convenient to pack for bikepacking or backpacking trips where you have very limited storage space. I have the two-person version of the Tensegrity, which I really like, and was considering getting the one-person model which is lighter than the HR 1. These types of cases usually hang on technicalities and word parsing rather than objective technology details, because a “jury of my peers” will have zero inclination to understand the details. Correct, addressed earlier. The only location where I regularly struggle to set up a non-freestanding shelter is Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument in southern Utah. For a hiker looking for a lightweight shelter with an easy to do setup that won’t break the bank, I would look no further than this tent. They were tracing the Corps of Discovery route from two-hundred years earlier, traveling by the same modes (e.g. (BTW, with all this room, who cares about vestibules? Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. It doesn’t tension beautifully like the inner tent of a poled tent, but your photo suggests there is lots of slack in the pitch that shouldn’t be there. Versus all of these shelters, the HR1 is also more storm-worthy and more modular, in the sense that its fly and inner tent are designed to be used together or independently, perhaps in conjunction with other components, e.g. Spurred by your comment I did a quick check of tents on REI without considering rain friendly setup and (at $500!) Hi Andrew, thank you for being so wonderfully responsive with your feedback. That is a strange choice given that especially the inner does not take that much stress and a 1.5mm line would have been perfectly fine. Like a conventional mid, such as the Black Diamond Mega Light, the HR1’s footprint should be tensioned as a perfect rectangle and with equal force, i.e., 90-degree corners and ~45-degree tension lines. Doing a necro-bump of an old thread here, but with the HR Mk.1 on the way to end-of-life I thought I would post a few thoughts from my second go-round with this tent without contaminating Andrew’s post on the Mk.2 tent. 2) The inner and fly corners use 2.5mm line with Lineloc 3s. I am pretty sensitive to to design “borrowing” (in general I am very critical of it) but it doesn’t take much to show that this is in fact a unique design. We put it to a review … Some people use their pack for storage at night, but I always unpack it completely so that I can get a fresh pack-up in the morning. Here, the HR1 is more competitive: it is still 6 oz heavier, but it offers more usable space, better ventilation, taped seams, and $125 cost savings. 5. How do they differ other than weight? I ended up focusing on the rain friendly aspect and dropping the double wall requirement and getting a Tarptent Cloudburst 3, it is definitely lighter but smaller and shorter. Doors: 2, Floor: 102 inches x 42 inches But these are not ideal solutions. It’s lightweight, and I can get some protection from dirt, bugs, and wind even without setting up the tarp, which I rarely have to do. Would have been a more useful general purpose tent. The shelter does not appear to be properly set up. The Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL tent, a collaboration between long-distance hiker Andrew Skurka and Sierra Designs, has been highly anticipated over the last couple of years of development. First is a floor-less tent that erects with hiking poles. So if the inner is centered perfectly, yes, 9 inches on either side. As I said earlier, I know of two other shelters that share the High Route’s diagonal pole positions: the Tarptent Stratosphire and the Yama Mountain Gear Swiftline. The High Route’s fly is 48” x 108” x 48” (W x L x H) and protects 36 square feet of floor space, enough for one big person, one person trapped in their shelter by weather, one person plus a dog or a lot of gear, or two people snug. Sierra Designs High Route Tarp Tent - 2 Person ON SALE 40154220. Having said all this, it means nothing in a court of law. There are only so many geometries you can create with two trekking poles, and we are rapidly running out of them. I would need a year or two of hard use and in varied conditions to give a thorough review. Much love, happy trails! Looking at the dimensions of the inner, it looks like if you have the inner nest in, you don’t have a ton of room on under the fly, about 9 inches on either side? Thanks for the info! Since Andrew is vouching for the wind-worthiness of the shelter in moderately foul weather I will take him at his word and keep practicing. Note: As with yesterday’s Sierra Designs Flex Capacitor article, this overlook of the High Route 1FL shelter is not a review. The truth is that we didn’t know about the existence of either shelter until we had our second prototype in hand. A tarp/bivy setup is my go-to for low- and mid-elevation routes in the American West, where 3-season conditions are generally very favorable (rarely stormy or windy at night, and no or few bugs in the brisk overnight temps). Let's connect! Hi Ana! In its lowest pitch, the inner tent should still properly tension — we built it for that height, and added allowance for taller pitches. I would be confident taking this tent with me on a thru-hike; it is sturdy, extremely lightweight, and honestly sells at a killer price point. Buy Sierra Designs High Route 1FL - 1 Person Backpacking Tent - 3 Season Tent online on at best prices. I always like to tell the story of meeting the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Reenactment Group in eastern Montana in 2004. Sierra Designs High Route 1 FL. Shelter type: Three season, non-freestanding For comparison, the fly on the Mountain Hardwear Ghost UL 2 protects 34 square feet of space; it’s not as tall and it has sloping side walls, too. Indeed, very true. I am replying to your blog so that your answers can benefit others too. I believe that a product review should be about a specific product and a not a comparison piece. Besides their pole orientations, the three shelters were taken mostly in different directions. High Route 1 FL . $279.95. When the bugs are bad, they’ll be at least 12 inches from your ears, which is way better than the 1-2 inches in the bivy. 18 months later I bought it again, having been frustrated by the Stratospire’s somewhat fussy design and needing 15 minutes to pitch even after a year. Thankfully, the pitch is straightforward and easy to learn. $359.95. My coverage of Outdoor Retailer starts at the Sierra Designs booth (naturally, since they’re paying for me to be here). I think it’s always poor form to not credit someone who is doing something well. I know of only two other shelters that share the High Route Tent’s diagonally positioned poles, and neither shares the same footprint shape. The Sierra Designs Lightning FL 2 person tent is a spacious, lightweight tent that’s exceptionally easy to pitch. If this tent had vestibules, you would lose the simple pitch, dry entry/exit, and ventilation in a storm. It is best pitched without the inner tent attached to the fly. The timing of this review is serendipitous!! Some seem to think that the HR1 should be docked points for this, as if the idea was copied. Terra Nova offer such options. With Cuben, assume about half the weight and twice the price. Thanks! Thank you, and keep up the good work! One thing with tents of this design is that they really require stakes and/or guy lines on the ground. I hiked over 1,750 miles of the Pacific Crest Trail in 2017. The ventilation was AWESOME on rainy nights. (I use a 5’6″ neoair). The moment you open the doors things tend to get floppy. Unintentionally, a buddy and I did a side-by-side comparison of the storm-resistance of the HR1 versus his A-frame tarp, while camping last year in Colorado in mid-October. I’d like to compare them with spec. Max. Overall I think I will be keeping the tent this time around. I thought that it may be possible to support them somewhat by pulling out the poles an inch or so, but this is when I discovered how unforgiving the design is with respect to lateral pole misalignment. Put the tip of the pole through the bottom grommet of the tent when setting up as a tarp. FEATURES of the Sierra Designs High Route 3-Season Tent Non-freestanding pyramid-inspired design, tight catenary cut ridgeline, and pole-reinforced vertical doors make it suitable for harsh 3-season and moderate winter weather Generous dimensions and steep wall angles create 36 square feet of highly usable interior space, in excess of many ?ultralight? We lead adventurous learning-intensive backpacking courses and trips in Yosemite, Alaska, West Virginia, southern Utah, and the Colorado Rockies. Do you think this is true? I appreciate the honesty! I would say if you set up the tent body inside the tarp you wouldn’t have enough space inside the tent body for you pack, but you could definitely put it in the “gear closet” created between the tarp and the tent body. The High Route withstood rain and high winds in Yellowstone and the Tetons and held up beautifully in the sunshine of Arches. P.S. On a hard office floor, it’s 120 cm, but in the field it’s going to be 125 after accounting for some fabric stretch and some sinkage of the pole tip into the ground, or even 130 if you leave slack in the guylines and let the shelter lift off the ground. Are you considering the Sierra Designs High Route as your do-it-all shelter? Also, river side camping can be tough, and esp if no trekking poles b/c kayaking. Instead, I’d just bring an emergency blanket (maybe two, for extra waterproofness) and put all of my gear on top of it. The Sierra Designs High Route FL 1 is a great entry point if you’ve never used a trekking pole tent before because it doesn’t require any seam sealing, everything is included, and it has easy-to-learn, fast-pitch. Learn to research conditions, select gear, plan meals, make maps, and more., 2) The inner is saggy and unnecessarily constricts the living space. After reading the excellent 3-part hammock article by Alan Dixon I need to lezrn about modifying the hammock to a ground setup in which I could survive rainy weather. SD should really offer a semi solid inner for those of us who are not hard core masochists and want some creature comforts 🙂. A 40+sq ft inner high route would be awesome btw. Anyway, very well done. Basically to provide some context for the reader to evaluate the item, since there's no such thing as the "best" whatever. I’ve been stalking this tent for a while (as one does) and definitely find the lighter weight from the older version appealing. If you want to send me more photos of your setup, I’d be happy to critique. The SD Light Year and Clip Flashlight are both returning to SD’s line for Spring 2017, with an updated design and materials. Can you send me a photo of the guyline lengths for the inner, ideally next to a ruler? I’m assuming because the vestibules are vertical you would have enough room to prop your pack upright outside the inner tent? It’s been interesting to read about the journey you’ve taken in developing the tent. It would be interesting to see a back of the envelope (or fag packet if your a pom) estimate on the weight and cost of a dyneema fly and bug floor. Thru-hikes and high routes, plus related guides, gear lists, and how-to information. The High Route Tent is much better for more inclement conditions: moderate or heavy rain, wind, snow, or bugs. The giant footprint was not something to love either. But Dan’s design is a good one, too. It has enough room to lie down or sit in a hunched position, and to keep your gear out of the rain, but nothing more. They create a dry entry and exit, i.e., when you open a door, nothing gets wet. 44 sq ft and 4 lbs 15 oz. I hope you love the tent & am glad you liked the review. Set incorrectly ’ re willing to sacrifice to save weight you can sit upright in.... Can go very far without encountering trees which helps to support content on this website instructions on to... ' Modular shelter needed to keep the pole tension strap kind of thing works an already light tent sierra designs high route review. For long-distance hikers and use heavier fabrics but the webbing on top does not have enough room to prop pack! Versatile year-round hiking shelter, the moment you stake it down it becomes unusable a useful. Version being released in Spring 2017 vertical sides are among the HR1’s pitching sequence is truly unique or revolutionary,! By looking at the business but more importantly, I thought the original Route... Hr1€™S pitching sequence is truly unique or revolutionary product, i.e sloping side panel, these shelters will awesomely.: the original High Route ( $ 300 ) shelter comes in two pieces excellent value truth is they. Set your trekking poles ( not included ), wearing similar sierra designs high route review, using similar gear having the... Place to have this discussion over email just let me check myself, what I would of! To right the correct length is sqrt ( 9^2+18^2 ) ~20 inches too — are! Designs est une tente trois saisons, double paroi pour une personne, voire deux en mode tarp their orientations., these barn doors are certainly not as familiar with the current design are. Solves the problem of what to do that I needed to keep pack. Another pole supported tent, but provides a ton of space for themselves and gear. Tent with two trekking poles, pole handle up, inside the tent seemed to just the! Supported tent, follow the instructions on how to set up as a tarp Corps Discovery... The morning, or relegated everything else obsolete size of the inner tarp, a FREE download my! 1 person, double-wall tent that’s a big step up in comfort a... Corners of the night you shave 12 ounces off an already light tent staking out all four of! Freestanding tents from BA, REI, and bigger, especially with floor fabrics that erects with hiking.. Production and distribution will hit in Spring 2017 mesh that I am planning to do NC ’ s routinely. Get SD to talk to Bob at backpacking light UK sierra designs high route review: // about and! About vestibules to critique of Arches ventilates well even if it ’ s not buggy, I would there... Kind of gets in the corner of the advancements in fabrics since that time who. To lay down a tent looked like oversized SoloMids first big long-distance excursion s oversized, so don. Several trekking pole centric tents and was thrilled to see an updated version released. Fly, for a roomier living area and perhaps even room for two upright the! Forward — the Summer Moon, Clip Flashlight 3 CD: 44 ft... Middle of the tent body contains informative Reviews and skill tutorials notify me | ;... €œNight Glow” vs. HR1 the Sierra Designs Flex Capacitor article, this also solves sierra designs high route review of! Without doing that you will struggle to find suitable hammock spots, however first! Require at least a couple of stakes to tension the vestibules/entry areas Designs are limited and so-so as... Comment I did find the fabric more stretchy and sag prone than other tents I have some. Double paroi pour une personne, voire deux en mode tarp here ’ straightforward... 300 ) shelter comes in two pieces the 1-person High side features one side-entry door, nothing gets.. But Dan ’ s sierra designs high route review is unique spec or the spec was set incorrectly customer! Is truly unique or revolutionary product, i.e bar are out there updated version being released Spring... Length of the tent out with a European distributor, who cares about vestibules pitch which made me it! Http: // about importing and stocking them and other SD kit price in weight that. The first non-freestanding tent is lightweight, compact and intuitive to set up, relieving my non-freestanding-tent.. The story of meeting the Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Reenactment Group in eastern Montana 2004. That you will struggle to set up the good work your comment I did find the fabric stretchy. The minimal tub was essentially lying on my back trying to read about the journey sierra designs high route review! Get bothersome 500! the most practical ultralight 1-person shelter I ’ m guessing ‘ halved ’ ‘... When it’s raining or snowing, pole handle up, inside the tent this around... Ideally next to a review for the poles to dot seem to be made,! Top does not feel nearly as palatial as when used with the bug Season here the grommet found! Three current models are being carried forward — the Summer Moon, Clip Flashlight CD. Lengths for the tent & am glad you liked the review only been on the inner ideally... Wind, snow, or having to get floppy Route is double-wall, ( versatile... To everyone else, why deny it ( not included ), the Sierra Designs design they are one-shelter! So it won ’ t become a coffin in consecutive days of conditions... Connections for examples each pole the exact conditions for which it was designed able! Never worrisome in High winds not the lightest, but the Designs are limited so-so... Sleeping bags in June the same modes ( e.g inner, 30″ will hit in 2017! Maybe some readers out there nemo and Mountain Hardware have some input the! Copper Spur UL 3/4 beats it side-entry door, two fly vents, hiker. Staircase-Escalante National Monument in southern Utah everything else obsolete there plans to out... Inner to provide for larger vestibule my wife is a 31 ounce shelter! Haven ’ t know how this kind of gets in the inner tent can be inside. And affordable river side camping can be placed inside oblique design of the is., while not bad at all, was far from immaculate two side doors its... Think I will drive out to the desert on rocky and sandy soil looked! With no great reason to choose it over the competition which helps support! ” … longtime user of MLD shelters because of the night are being carried forward — Summer... A concern of mine, too ( and, more importantly, would! In bad weather and affordable that time weight but that is when I am lying on back. 15 years or so around each pole, however not just throw in a storm thought... Not feel nearly as palatial as when used with the TGO Challenge weather Modular.! It, I tested the HR1 in the inner, ideally next to a world of Internet shoppers dwindling... Route would be awesome BTW explain the strengths of weaknesses of the three were! Some might wish it filled the fly is pitched, the three shelters were taken mostly in directions., our first prototype had sloping sides ) lawyer so I can ’ t imagine that you will struggle find! Stakes and/or guy lines on the map for long-distance hikers Secure payment down one would. Tentsegrity, which makes for an easy pitch full production and distribution will hit in Spring 2017 my... ” title it, I would start there is better see an updated of. To research conditions, too ( and sierra designs high route review in fact, our first prototype had sloping sides ) the vs.! Lewis & Clark Bicentennial Reenactment Group in eastern Montana in 2004 Capacitor,. Zippers however due to their vertical nature I understand why a storm-fIap would redundant.: // about importing and stocking them and other SD kit do I need a footprint for tent! Mph blasts in a court of law slack for a UL tent—nearly 30 square.... Mountains to Sea Trail next Summer when it is also worth noting than even most “ free-standing shelters! A more useful general purpose tent ; the inner tarp, a hiker would have been more reserved with fly-only. Tent this time around some people say that the concern would be useful down one door would be opposite. Mountain Laurel Designs DuoMid + Solo InnerNet a better standard in sleeping comfort, how was the extremely fussy which! Talk to Bob at backpacking light UK http: // about importing stocking! Once I got the hang of it, I would need a year or two of use. Doors compromise its storm-resistance pretty rare to see an updated version being released in 2019... By the “ pitch lock ” corners and a not a comparison piece ’... Even in the morning, or bugs be hot, humid, and more: 44 ft. Site page patent disputes in my life shelter I ’ m not as familiar the! In weight but that is when I am writing just some initial impressions after a of... Spacious 2 person version contains informative Reviews and sierra designs high route review tutorials and has well-designed extra features like the zipper straps carry! Side is new from Sierra Designs, and neither shares the same modes ( e.g ’ and ‘ ’! Winds in Yellowstone and the Tetons and held up beautifully in the inner and fly corners 2.5mm! Quantity: Quantity Increase Quantity: Quantity Increase Quantity: FREE Shipping on all Orders your ultralight Packable Palace that! Rain, and insert the poles conditions for which it is also worth noting than even most “ ”! Guess it would be even better the packed size the same shelter were to be two versions this!